There is no way to put a round in the chamber without leaving the striker cocked, and there is no safety. Notice if the trigger is ever depressed. Or some jackass was pocket carrying his G43 without a holster and something snagged the trigger. Long story short, I let it be known that I thought carrying with an empty chamber is a mistake. I lost a whitetail in heavy cover to the click when the safety is released. I've carried both extensively. Well, its nice to know Im negligible. They said that it was the fault of Glocks having a super light trigger. You would probably be more likely to survive in a Banzai charge. If I was gona carry an empty gun Id carry a full sized 1911, that way if I had to throw it at somebody it would weigh enough to hurt when it him them. PS: I have never had an ND with my EDC G23 chamber loaded these past 22 years. An unchambered gun is a dangerous, useless-to-you half measure. I am lacking a rapier and main gauche though so maybe not ready for the six fingered man. Knowing how impossible that is, Im NOT one of those. Bottom line: For *any* firearm, you have to *put your finger (or some other object) INTO the trigger guard to fire the weapon. Gunfights can happen that fast. Im so glad to have seen the one person who never makes a mistake! But do suggest they make more of them and lower the price for us plebes. Hmm that give away means youre at least in your 60s bordering on senility. As a matter of fact in an extreme emergency you could carry the HK with no holster and in your pocket or even waist band but if you did the same thing with a Glock you would quickly blow your balls off in short order. says: How often do you train your driving abilities?. I have had cops point shotgunms and Rvolvurs at me, made me nervous, now their pointing Glocks at me, and that frightens me to the point of shaking. I think it's more about . But, IF I were, then Id have to choose that DA revolver in my headboard. A GLOCK is a striker fired pistol with about a 5.5-pound OEM trigger pull that has incorporated into the trigger--in the form of a lever--and when it is engaged blocks the trigger from moving rearward. A forum community dedicated to Glock firearm owners and enthusiasts. Which, of course, is why its better to keep your self-defense gun be it a concealed carry pistol or home defense gun or whatever with a round in the chamber. Somewhat different than in rural MS tho, speaking as one who attended a full auto shoot at a local range about a month ago. the number of people out there who keep a single-action revolver as a home defense. The are a couple videos out there showing issues with holsters (kydex included) where bending or twisting caused a discharge. IMO, anyway. and so as to keep continuity in their mindset they keep that same gun on the headboard at night with no round in the chamber so that there wont be any confusion The Glock handgun is the preferred handgun of police worldwide. I have pocket carried for years, mostly using a clip such as a clip draw on my SIG 938, hammer down, safety on, round chambered. So the trigger pull is utterly irrelevant *if* you are paying attention to your firearm which you should be doing, again, with *any* firearm. Note, the sentry safe does have a security vulerablity that can be mitigated by covering a hole with stainless steel tape. Ive carried in condition one for nearly 25 years. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'guntradition_com-box-4','ezslot_7',110,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-guntradition_com-box-4-0');Some people are nervous about Glocks because they heard one rumor or another about them. If a person was going to leave a gun in Condition 3, they had better practice loading and firing the pistol, because not doing so just might get them killed. - I'm too old to still think I know everything. Carrying a Glock 26 or 27 in "conditon 1" (chambered) is comparable to carrying a loaded S&W Jframe revolver. Just that for most every use, there are other choices that are better. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Considering the capabilities of the average glock owner, in front of the muzzle is likely the safest place to be. link to What is a Pistol Caliber Carbine. I dont condemn those who carry a striker with one in the chamber. I wonder how it avoids the googlebots? Barnum should have said, There is a Moron born every minute so I guess I will have to say it for him. However, there still isnt a compelling reason to carry a gun or keeping one for home defense that isnt loaded which cant be gotten around with a bit of training, a bit of brains, or a bit of extra gear. We have lots more on the site to show you. Furthermore, every person I know or have talked to who does have a single-action revolver Rough Rider, Blackhawk or a replica has other guns that they use for those roles. Just go to there web site, or go to your gun store for more information. The good folks at Iver Johnson (related in name only to the company that exists today) developed a lifting bar that sat between the hammer and the primer of the cartridge. KAER adhere to the business philosophy of customer first, service first, quality first, and provide our customers with high-quality products and perfect service.. We are a professional manufacturer dedicated to the production of gun safes, safe box, pistol safe and other security products. When suddenly a rabbit rushes out of the brush, I sometimes forget to switch off the safety. Despite its . Most cap and ball revolvers have carry notches between the nipple notches. I carry with a round chambered in my autoloading handguns. To chamber or not to chamber? Glock likewise provides a slimline design, which integrates features from the Gen 3 and Gen 5 Glock guns. Well, now, lets analyze this a bit deeper, shall we? If youre going to do something like defend yourself with a firearm. Glock claims that this translates into longer pistol longevity as well as better accuracy overall. Not much difference really. Please note Im not saying glock = bad. That was back in the 1970s somewhere. Or a DA/SA auto. At least the DA/SA or DAO provide a long hard trigger pull. The best line of all time is Dirty Harrys. Its an unnatural, metallic noise that spooked him instantly, and I missed the snap shot at a running target, and he was gone. If all you do at the range is stand there at the bench, pick up your gun, lock the slide, insert the magazine, and press the slide stop to send the slide forward, then get on target to shoot, you're not training yourself right. On Firefox for Windows, it just goes to the top of the page, but it will still get the newest comments. Of course, when I was a soldier, I listened to guys who had been there. If you want a single action trigger pull, either carry a SAO autoloader in condition one, or choose a hammer fired model that one can manipulate its condition at will. So yes, its completely safe. I felt a few of the points that were raised had enough merit to discuss further. De nada. Keep your chin up, youll get it eventually. You can lift and close the bolt to cock the striker quicker than doing all four motions. The odds of a holster obstruction triggering a Glock in that case is an acceptable risk due to the greater risk of being too slow. Practice your procedure till it becomes a natural reaction without thinking.You will have other things that must be accessed in those fractions of a second. I still get the occasional email notification. Im not a big believer in the the bad guy will just take your gun and use it against you school of thought. Carrying with an empty chamber was John Waynes great advice, applicable to old, single action revolvers. So were really talking only about safe carry and capacity, as the first shot fired will be from the NEXT chamber. The Israelis do it, and I do too. The Glock Model 48 slimline 9mm is a state-of-the-art fighting pistol with a small grip frame any cop can master. like i said Width: 1.18. Glock 23 Handgun. The full magazine has ten rounds, and the "+1" is the round that is in the chamber. Never happened yet I would rather shoot myself in the leg but still be in fight than have bad guy shoot me because I didnt have a chambered round. They are: Glocks are completely drop-safe and are one of the safest pistols you can carry. THAT is a significant, even dangerous, error to be stating as fact. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[468,60],'guntradition_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_2',112,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-guntradition_com-large-leaderboard-2-0');I, as well as others, have tested and tried to get the Safe Action System, to fail but without actually modifying parts, we havent been able to. Kentucky CCDW Instructor. If the trigger safety is not depressed, the trigger will not move rearwards and allow the pistol to fire. P.T. MOLON LABE. For instance, you have Rugers Blackhawk and Vaquero models, Heritage Manufacturings Rough Rider series, replicas made by Pietta, Uberti and Cimarron and so on. The 1911 has a grip safety as well as a thumb safety. Some militaries wanted to normalize carrying a pistol or rifle with a loaded chamber for obvious reasons, but they ran into some of these same issues on old guns. Then you have the big, scary, single-action magnums by IWI (the BFR) Freedom Arms and custom guns from Jeff Linebaugh. We were assured that; were working on it. The trick is training is to do the right thing; doing the wrong thing is still training, just training the do the wrong thing. There are more and complicated details about the Israeli attitude (prohibition) of self-defense, but the point is that the Israeli system may work for the IDF, but not for you. That is a good point that I have never heard before. It would be as if a round was pushed into the ground, primer up, and then a firing pin dropped from a height, point down, directly into the primer. The gun is DA/SA, so the first shot is a long pull on the trigger, but I routinely practice it, so Im OK with it. Its a toughy. Still disagree? Heres a news flash, ever since Adam and Eve ate the serpents apple were all fallible. Some folks in the comments section raised objections, as they are often wont to do. This is the inherit design of a sticker fired pistol. Why would you do that more in a Glock than in *any other firearm*? Want to vent about something? Still chambered in 9mm, the G19 measures 7.28-inches in total length. I only know my own lifes experiences, fwiw, too many LEOs cant hit chit no matter what the tool, and Im an honorary. Frankly, most of us should be more concerned about our cholesterol anyway. The Glock 17 is a full-size pistol that is chambered in 9mm. The first click is there so the hammer isnt resting on the cartridge. Have you ever failed to yield the right of way when making a left turn? or not. As for me on striker fired Im sure they are just as safe as any other design I just like to see whats going on, . Have you ever negligently turned down the wrong way of a one way street? On TTAG anyone can use any name at any time, and that makes it really confusing. The Series 80 was a solution in search of a problem ie, it was created by lawyers. One was carrying a single action revolver without a transfer bar safety in a holster, and one under the hammer. Ammoland eh? Prices accurate at time of writing. Thats when I started looking for a better way. The Glock trigger is too light and too short to be safe, and I understand Glocks are way far overrepresented in the annals of ND, which is very easy to understand. Good luck!!!!! So the trigger safety is designed to prevent the pistol from firing if its dropped or if the trigger is subjected to any pressure that isnt a direct firing pull.Best practice is to keep your finger off the trigger until you are ready to fire. I think I can answer that one. Glock then redesigned the weapon as a striker fired weapon because they knew the average low I.Q. Smh. I dont understand why anyone who carries a modern firearm is afraid to carry a round in the chamber??? If I have to carry a compact, its a DA only with no safety or one with the safety off. Between the trigger safety, the firing pin safety and the drop safety I feel very comfortable carrying it chambered. On paper? . If you did not realize the design is dangerous, you would not have spent so much time belaboring the obvious. But youll likely carry for years and years, manipulating said weapon an uncountable number of times in the process. Please note, comments must be approved before they are published. Congratulations. Many revolvers also changed; whereas the firing pin was once integrated with the hammer . Glock 22 Gen 3 (Photo: Gunprime) The full-size Glock 22 was made to fill the gap between .45 and 9mm. I for one dont want to take the chance of fumbling around with a gun trying to rack the gun under pressure. 1. Please consider creating a . For 1911s, the danger is similar if you carry hammer down on a loaded chamber though I dont know why any somewhat intelligent person would do so. Of course all of those Glock NDs were due to human error. Obviously carrying concealed greatly reduces the odds of your gun being taken, but that doesnt mean that precautions arent in order. Is It Safe To Carry A Chambered Glock. Best thing you can do is buy a pistol that you can safely carry loaded with one in the chamber. Like: condition 2 (good choice for a DA/SA autoloader), condition 1 (if your chosen piece has a manual safety), and etc. Pray the gay away gov. You hit the nail on the head with "comfortable", but that is subjective. Youd figure Colt would have gotten with the program by now and made the SAA with a transfer bar. Ive run an experiment with a rough 1911 with a POS barrel that was scrap. In the 1930's, W.E. But Knute is fine, and nobody else seems to want it. There are a lot of older pistols manufactured without a drop safety feature. It has been many years since I saw that movie. I submit extremely unlikely. Are Glocks Safe To Carry Chambered. Much the less wish to discuss the merits of hammer mounted versus frame mounted firing pins, or the S&W design of using a rebound slide instead (my favorite design). The odds are not in favor of the added time it takes to try and chamber a round, let alone the stress of a real situation. If my gun lands at my childs feet, an empty chamber leaves plenty of time to prevent a tragedy, but a chambered striker-fired gun may not. Probably applies to a few other westerns as well though. To fire the pistol, the trigger safety and the trigger itself must be deliberately depressed at the same time. Modern revolvers (Smith & Wesson, Taurus, Ruger, Kimber) have transfer bar safeties and as such theres no need to mention it.. I carried it un-chambered for a few weeks till I was comfortable. No, but it requires that everything go right when theres a higher chance of something going wrong. You shoud not count on having both hands available while being attacked. Glocks have a feature that prevents the trigger from accidentally being pulled, blocks the firing pin until the trigger is fully pressed, and the pistol is not actually cocked until the trigger is puled. and self styled know it alls. That doesnt mean you can ever fool around with one. Eventually, revolver designs changed. More solid irrefutable proof that the Glock is an accident waiting to happen. "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." But in my house, in the middle of the night, what do I care about 50 yard accuracy or the ability to knock over a steel plate or knock a bowling pin off a table? You could also chamber a snap cap, holster it, do your daily routine around the house and then check if trigger was pulled. you roll the dice. As if every act of negligence is a deliberate act. The finger does not go in the trigger guard until Im ready to fire. What you are overlooking is the odds. Police departments across the country mocked the NYPD for their accusations and understood that its both trigger happy officers and training issues that lead to problems like that.Glocks two-part trigger is one piece of their internal safety features. I have done special work to lighten my trigger and its still not very touchy. I got rid of that one, I didnt really need it, but now, sigh, I wish I had it back. I do same with shotgun the last round fired stays in the chamber. Is it just something one has to get used to? They make it look soooo easy in the movies! Clearly not enough to train for scenarios where chambering a round can be life or death. Torture tests are silly and prove nothing about a gun. How often are you drinking a glass of milk, or spilling coffee, or having a horn tooted at you while actually handling or holstering your firearm? Whats the big deal? That was a few years ago now. If you cant respect the power and danger of an automobile why would you think you could be trusted with a firearm at all let alone one without a safety? 1911s are traditionally carried empty chamber (probably a bad idea) or cocked and locked: hammer cocked and slide mounted safety engaged. Maybe you should just use a spork. I appendix carry my 42 chambered, the holster covers the trigger so I feel safe carrying this way, I been carrying this way for a while without issue. We can talk about the merits of being able to shoot effectivly one handed. I could carry Israeli style, I suppose, and draw-and-rack if it comes to that, but I just saw a training video in which a woman carrying Israeli style would have been killed by a knife had the attack been real. Ive dropped a loaded Glock once, actually the only pistol Ive ever dropped in my life. One of the interesting things about that is I can (after clearing) dry fire repeatedly and get a rough visual about how much the aim point moves depending on my grip and finger position. Said every one of the people who later came to suffer from glock leg. I have trained chambering on the draw and while it is less effective it still gives me options. Personally I dont just carry for my own personal defense, but also the defense of my country, my comrades and other citizens. Ehall my pistolas are chambered with the safety engaged-at home. Unlikely. As I mentioned elsewhere here, the trigger pull and safety mechanism are irrelevant to the *proximate* cause of any Glock discharge Im aware of. ended up in the guys nostril, and he still didnt get quiet, until he heard the cocking of the hammer. You have entered an incorrect email address! This also means that if the firing pin somehow gets enough inertia to hit the primer, from some other source than the hammer (whatever that source might be), and then the round in front of the pin suddenly ceases motion, the firing pin will continue forward into the round anyway, no matter what the hammer, trigger, barrel, or etc, do. But now at my age I know me and I know my weapons and youll be gambling with your life if you engage me thinking you know whether there is one in the chamber. One other one was very tragic. They are built using the patented Safe Action System which prevents unintentional firing. israeli carry is stupid. Its an unsafe design from 2 aspects, the fact that it acts much like a single action weapon with the hammer cocked back and no manual safety and it has a totally unsafe asinine take down system. Concerning long guns that are stored for home defense, I think that "cruiser ready" is the ideal state of readiness for rifles or shotguns. It has a safety, but I dont really care about that. Few indeed even care about SA revolvers anymore, or even know they exist, or care about the firing mechanism. Of course theres a difference between driving and shooting. Because they have no external safety, Glocks are quicker to draw and fire. Lol. I thought I counted 17 in the battle scene in Open Range. My opinion. carrying or keeping a gun with a round in the chamber, Standard Manufacturings New S333 Revolver Fires Two .22 WMR Rounds at a Time, District of Columbia AG Subpoenas NRA Foundation Financial Records, Gov. Have you ever tried carrying your bolt action on a loaded round with the striker down? Mike Cumpston [Public domain], via Wikimedia CommonsCredit where due, its true that in days long past the best practice was to carry your revolver with the hammer resting on an empty chamber or on an empty primer nipple in pre-cartridge pistols. There are 5 in the house right now; computer room (where I am) living room, bathroom floor (beside the throne) and both sides of the bed. The fix was to add a safety. There are some days (summer, mostly) when I carry the Walther PK380. You can conceal the Glock 43 comfortably and discretely in a Galco leather holster like the . All that said, training, knowledge of your firearms design/function, and practice go a long way to make any firearm safe to carry with a round chambered though some designs are better for a particular purpose. The priming compound could care less WHAT hits it, so long as the blow has sufficient energy to activate the explosive charge in the primer, it will detonate. The S&W EZ has a grip safety and a good trigger pull. My Taurus G2C is DAO, restrike, and no mag safety. Make that line above into: a solution in search of a problem. https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/the-truth-about-6-5mm-ammo/ Let's talk about wh. I know some people , maybe most people , will be just fine carrying a Glock with a loaded chamber , but all the reasons people give for not are not 100% wrong either . So you have no quibble with the line; If dropped, the hammer could contact the primer and therefore, fire., in relation to SA revolvers? One common question among Glock owners is whether or not they can shoot aluminum cased ammunition in their . i carry mostly to counter the mass shooting incident the type of which where afterward everybody says if there had only been a good guy with a gun and i will more likely than not have time to draw the weapon and charge it while i get my ooda loop going. Sub-one second times, under stress are the norm when properly trained. It is a compact pistol that is chambered in 9mm and is designed for concealed carry. Theyre both safe and useful within their own parameters, and people are free to choose the one they prefer. Does anyone ride the hammer down on their gun with a LIVE ROUND in the chamber? No safety needs to include a stiff, lengthy trigger pull, like the LC9, or a DA revolver. Excuse me, but the inventor of the Linebaugh cartridges and custom gunsmith in Powell Wyoming is JOHN Linebaugh. In my 3-screw, yes. So you think youre perfect look in the mirror clown I am not trying to get an A here I really wonder if you can shoot at all like getting rounds on the target I think I hurt your feelings again wha what wha. A 16 year old In drivers ed may not be very experienced nor skilled, but at least in my day, was paying more attention than a driver more familiar with driving. I didnt mention this stuff because in the original post because the number of people out there who keep a single-action revolver as a home defense or self-defense gun is likely negligible. On one of those occurances, my snubbie bbl. A revolver with an empty chamber under the hammer IS ready to fire. Didnt say I didnt know how, just not much use for one Bad guy dies. People that just cant accept what someone else wants to do compared to what they feel is best for them smacks of their insecurity. Usually I just get to see Colt SAAs with 16 chamber cylinders. All I get is replies that they are working on it. I got them after watching the best experts I know of, champions, and their green light review. Human brains arent too sure of themselves, and if an expected result does not occur, our brain responds by doing the action again, just to make sure it did it the first time. Thats a lot more true to life (in my admittedly inexperienced opinion) than most movies, especially westerns. If you 're considering a Glock handgun, make sure you have an armorer or gunsmith install it before trying to customize it. Here's video that GLOCK produced that explains the trigger safety. Perhaps you could write one yourself even. It was being carried in an improper holster or the operator got careless in putting the pistol back into the holster, by not making sure the path was clear. I used to carry a Walther PPQ. Often, its holstering the gun into a holster that compromised by clothing. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. This makes it about five ounces lighter than another popular 9mm Luger gun, the Glock 19. I am thinking G2S, my ankle sometimes gets chilly, but, Im happy with my PA-63 In 918, and I have a CZ, in 918, that has the best SA trigger Ive ever felt, since the Smith S.S. Model 66, .357 which was accurized, and tweaked by a smith, that was flat out dangerous, hair wasnt the word. I dont have to hit a bypass cause its cocked, or turn off a safety, just pump and fire. They do have a half cock notch that you could use to carry on a loaded chamber, but theres a reason they say, Dont go off half-cocked. @ mark s: +1 here. Which raises the question: How tough can it possibly be to fix? Many striker/plastic pistols, like the S&W Sygma, have actual DA triggers, that do not use glocks UN safe-action trigger scheme. Even pistols with no manual safety, like this Glock, are safe to carry with a round chambered. Use whatever gun you want. It's a small handgun that is easy to carry, chambered for a very powerful cartridge, and priced so a working man can easily afford it. Modern revolvers with some sort of disconnect can be carried full up. Some extras, just in case one breaks? Yes. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! For me I often carry without one in the chamber, like when I am in the woods doing stuff. This is a particularly great idea. Usually for at least an hour or so. But that would be true for almost ANY gun that didnt have a manual safety engaged. I am sure you will tell us that since you are a stable genius it will never happen to you. I tease my friends when I can see their chamber indicator, I listened to guys who had been there.. A S&W Model 329. So I traded it. Wouldnt it be actually quicker to rack the slide than to retrieve your weapon from a locked box? Like what would happen if the gun was dropped, and then lands on its muzzle. Glock 17. A lot of guns, particularly the early revolvers, were considered too dangerous to carry with a loaded chamber because a sharp bump or drop could cause it to fire.